Healing Fantasies: The Subconscious Hope That Keeps You Trapped

You've imagined it a thousand times. The moment they finally see you. The breakthrough where they understand the pain they've caused and become the person you always knew they could be. You've rehearsed conversations in your head, believing that if you just find the right words, the right approach, the right moment – everything will change.

This isn't foolish hope. This is a healing fantasy – a powerful psychological phenomenon that affects millions of people in emotionally abusive relationships. Understanding why we develop these fantasies is the first step toward finally breaking free.

What Is a Healing Fantasy?

A healing fantasy is the deep, often subconscious belief that your abuser, neglectful parent, or emotionally unavailable partner will eventually transform into the loving, supportive person you desperately need them to be. It's the persistent hope that keeps you waiting, trying harder, and staying just a little longer.

As Lindsay C. Gibson explains in Adult Children of Emotionally Immature Parents: "Having immature parents forces children to adjust to their parents' emotional limitations. Children react to emotionally immature parenting in a number of ways as they attempt to be noticed, cared for, and engaged with. But the one thing all emotionally deprived children have in common is coming up with a fantasy about how they will eventually get what they need."

These fantasies don't disappear when we grow up. They follow us into our adult relationships, often intensifying when we encounter partners who recreate familiar patterns of emotional unavailability, manipulation tactics, or outright abuse.

The Origins of Healing Fantasies

Childhood Roots

Most healing fantasies begin in childhood. When a parent is emotionally immature, narcissistic, or abusive, children cannot simply leave. They're completely dependent on their caregivers, so their psyche develops protective mechanisms – chief among them, hope.

A child who believes their parent could love them properly (if only they were good enough, quiet enough, successful enough) feels less helpless than a child who accepts their parent simply cannot provide what they need. The fantasy serves as emotional survival.

This childhood pattern becomes a template. We learn early that love is something to be earned, that we must wait for others to be capable of meeting our needs, and that our persistent hope and patience might eventually unlock the love we crave.

The Role of Intermittent Reinforcement

Healing fantasies are dramatically strengthened by intermittent reinforcement – the unpredictable pattern of receiving affection, validation, or kindness. Just when you've lost hope, they show you a glimpse of the person you fell in love with. They apologize. They're tender. They promise change.

These moments, however brief, feel like evidence that your fantasy is realistic. See? They CAN be loving. It IS possible. The occasional reward keeps you invested, much like a gambler who keeps playing because they won once and believe they can win again.

Dr. Patrick Carnes, who pioneered research on trauma bonding, found that this unpredictable reinforcement creates addiction-like attachment. Your brain releases dopamine during positive moments, creating a neurological craving for those experiences – and strengthening the fantasy that more of them will come.

Why We Cling to the Healing Fantasy

1. Cognitive Dissonance Is Painful

Your mind holds two conflicting truths: "This person hurts me" and "I love this person." The psychological tension between these beliefs is excruciating. The healing fantasy resolves this dissonance by adding a third element: "...but they will change."

This allows you to maintain your emotional attachment while acknowledging the pain. You don't have to choose between love and self-preservation because, in your fantasy, you'll eventually have both. You're not staying in an abusive relationship; you're waiting for the relationship to become what it always had the potential to be.

2. The "Good Person" Feels Real

Abusers aren't abusive 100% of the time. The charming, attentive person you fell in love with – or the warm moments with a difficult parent – feel genuine. When they're kind, you see their "true self." When they're cruel, that must be an aberration, a response to stress, a wound you can help them heal.

But as Amy Marlow-MaCoy writes in The Gaslighting Recovery Workbook: "Gaslighting is a form of psychological and emotional abuse that causes victims to question their reality, judgment, self-perception, and, in extreme circumstances, their sanity. Gaslighters distort truth to manipulate, confuse, and control their victims."

The "good person" you're waiting for may have always been a mask – a calculated presentation designed to hook you and keep you invested. The cruelty isn't the aberration; it's the relationship operating as intended.

3. Leaving Means Accepting Loss

Abandoning your healing fantasy requires grieving multiple losses simultaneously:

• The relationship you hoped for that never existed
• Your investment of time, energy, emotion, and perhaps years of your life
• Your self-image as someone who can love anyone into changing
• Your family structure if the person is a parent or co-parent
• Your identity which has been wrapped around being their partner/child/helper

This grief feels unbearable. It's often easier to maintain the fantasy than to face the full weight of these losses. But as long as you're waiting for change that will never come, you're losing more time – and more of yourself.

4. Society Reinforces the Fantasy

Cultural messages constantly reinforce healing fantasies:

• "Love conquers all"
• "People can change"
• "Stand by your partner through thick and thin"
• "Family comes first"
• "Marriage is about commitment"

These messages aren't entirely wrong in healthy relationships. But when applied to abusive dynamics, they become weapons that keep victims trapped. You're not staying because you're foolish; you're staying because everything you've been taught suggests you should.

The Sobering Truth: Do Narcissists Ever Change?

This is the question at the heart of every healing fantasy: Will they change?

The honest answer is complicated but important to understand:

Change Is Possible, But Extremely Rare

Research suggests that meaningful change in narcissists and emotional abusers requires:

1. Genuine acknowledgment of their behavior and its impact (not defensive excuses or DARVO responses)
2. Sustained professional treatment with a therapist experienced in personality disorders
3. Their own motivation to change – not just promises made to keep you from leaving
4. Years of consistent effort with accountability
5. No expectation that you wait for them

Most abusers never meet these conditions. Many lack the self-awareness to recognize their behavior as problematic. Others make surface-level changes to prevent consequences, then revert to old patterns once the threat of loss passes – a cycle familiar to anyone who's experienced hoovering.

The Change You're Hoping For Isn't Yours to Create

You cannot love someone into mental health. You cannot be patient enough, forgiving enough, or understanding enough to transform another person's fundamental patterns. Change is internal work that only they can do.

As Gibson observes about emotionally immature parents: these individuals have "emotional limitations" that developed over their entire lifetime. Your relationship with them, no matter how devoted, cannot undo decades of ingrained patterns.

Waiting Isn't Free

Every day you spend hoping they'll change is a day you're not:

• Building healthy relationships
• Healing your own wounds
• Pursuing your goals and dreams
• Experiencing what healthy love feels like
• Protecting your children from witnessing (and learning) these patterns

The cost of waiting is your life. And you deserve better than to spend your limited years in a fantasy that exists only in your mind.

Recognizing Your Healing Fantasy

How do you know if you're caught in a healing fantasy? Look for these patterns:

You Focus on Their Potential, Not Their Patterns

You see who they could be rather than who they consistently are. You remember who they were during love bombing and believe that person is their authentic self, just waiting to re-emerge.

You Make Excuses Based on Their History

"They had a difficult childhood." "They're dealing with stress." "They don't know any better." While these explanations might be true, they don't change your experience of being mistreated – and understanding someone's wounds doesn't obligate you to absorb them.

You Keep Trying New Approaches

If only you communicate better, set clearer boundaries, give them more space, give them less space, are more understanding, are firmer... You've become a scientist running endless experiments, believing the right formula will finally unlock their transformation.

Your Hope Persists Despite Evidence

You've seen the same patterns repeat for months or years. They've broken the same promises multiple times. Yet somehow, you still believe "this time will be different."

You Feel Guilty About Protecting Yourself

When you think about leaving, stepping back, or setting firm boundaries, you feel like you're abandoning them. Your healing fantasy has convinced you that your presence is essential to their eventual transformation.

Breaking Free from the Healing Fantasy

1. Grieve What Never Was

The relationship you wanted doesn't exist and never did. This is a profound loss that deserves to be mourned. Allow yourself to grieve not just the relationship, but the future you imagined, the family you hoped to have, the love you deserved but didn't receive.

This grief may feel endless at first. That's normal. You're not just ending a relationship; you're releasing a lifeline you've clung to, perhaps since childhood.

2. Face the Pattern, Not Just the Incidents

Stop evaluating the relationship based on individual incidents ("Well, they didn't yell at me today") and examine the overall pattern. If someone hurts you predictably, repeatedly, and shows no evidence of sustained change, that IS who they are.

Write down specific incidents. Note dates, what happened, how you felt. When you're tempted to hope again, review this record. Let the pattern speak louder than individual moments.

3. Shift Your Focus to Your Own Healing

The only person whose change you can control is yourself. Redirect the energy you've spent hoping for their transformation toward your own recovery. Therapy, support groups, self-education, and healing from trauma bonding are investments that will actually pay off.

4. Limit Exposure

Distance provides clarity. When you're constantly in the relationship, their manipulations and your own attachment make it nearly impossible to see clearly. Space – whether physical, emotional, or through gray rock techniques – allows your healing fantasy to lose its grip.

5. Build Your Support System

Healing fantasies thrive in isolation. Reconnect with friends and family. Join support groups for survivors of emotional abuse. Surround yourself with people who reflect your worth back to you instead of people who diminish it.

6. Replace the Fantasy with Reality

When you catch yourself fantasizing about their change, redirect to reality:

• What have they actually done (not promised)?
• How do you actually feel most of the time?
• What has staying actually cost you?
• What would you tell a friend in your situation?

The truth is uncomfortable, but it sets you free.

The Path Forward Is Your Own Healing

Here's the liberating truth: Your life doesn't depend on their change. Your healing doesn't require their transformation. Your happiness isn't contingent on them finally becoming who you needed them to be.

You've spent so much energy waiting, hoping, and trying. Imagine channeling that energy into yourself instead. Into building the life you deserve. Into relationships where you don't have to wonder if the other person will hurt you today. Into becoming the person you want to be, free from the weight of someone else's limitations.

The healing fantasy promises that one day, they'll give you what you need. But you can give those things to yourself – peace, stability, self-respect, and love that doesn't hurt. That's not settling; that's choosing yourself.

Your fantasy was born from a child's desperate hope that their parent would finally see them, love them, choose them. That child deserved so much more. And so do you, right now, today – not someday when they finally change, but immediately, because you're worth it.

The only path forward is your own healing. Not theirs. Yours.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a narcissist ever truly change?

While change is theoretically possible, it requires genuine self-awareness, sustained professional treatment, personal motivation (not just fear of losing you), and years of consistent effort. Most narcissists lack the insight or motivation to meet these conditions. Importantly, even if change is possible, you're not obligated to wait for it – your well-being matters now.

How do I know if my hope is a healing fantasy or realistic optimism?

Realistic optimism is based on consistent evidence of change – not promises, but sustained different behavior over extended periods. Healing fantasies ignore repeated patterns and cling to potential instead of reality. Ask yourself: "What has actually changed, measurably and consistently?" If the answer is nothing, you're dealing with a fantasy.

Why can't I stop hoping they'll change even though I know better?

Healing fantasies often develop in childhood as survival mechanisms and are reinforced by intermittent reinforcement. They're not weaknesses or delusions – they're deeply ingrained psychological patterns. Breaking free requires understanding (not shaming yourself), sustained effort, and often professional support. Be patient with yourself while being honest about reality.

How long should I wait to see if someone changes?

If you've been waiting for years without seeing consistent, sustained change (not just promises or brief improvements), you have your answer. Change happens through actions over time, not through promises in moments of crisis. There's no specific timeline, but if you're asking this question, you likely already know enough.

What if they're in therapy – shouldn't I give them a chance?

Therapy attendance alone isn't evidence of change. What matters is sustained behavioral change outside of therapy. Many people use therapy attendance as proof of effort while continuing harmful patterns. Focus on whether you're actually experiencing a different relationship, not whether they're checking boxes.