Informed Consent for AI Therapy: Legal Guide

Informed consent in AI therapy ensures patients understand how AI tools are used in their mental health care, including potential risks, benefits, and privacy safeguards. With AI increasingly integrated into therapy - via chatbots, emotional analysis, or real-time monitoring - patients must have clear, voluntary options to participate or opt out.

Key takeaways:

• Transparency: Patients need clear explanations of AI’s role, limitations, and data use.
• Privacy: Data must comply with HIPAA and other laws, with robust encryption and minimal data collection.
• Legal Compliance: U.S. regulations like HIPAA, 42 CFR Part 2, and state laws (e.g., California AB 3030) govern AI use in therapy.
• Ethical Standards: Consent is not one-time; it requires regular updates and patient check-ins.

Therapists and organizations must combine clear communication, rigorous privacy measures, and adherence to evolving laws to ensure trust and ethical care.

NEW PODCAST EPISODE! AI in Therapy: Navigating Ethics and Confidentiality As AI continues to

Legal Foundations and U.S. Regulations

Navigating the legal landscape is essential for ensuring informed consent in AI therapy. In the United States, this means balancing long-standing healthcare laws with newer regulations tailored to AI. These rules are critical for providers, developers, and patients alike.

Key Legal Frameworks Overview

HIPAA, the Healthcare Information Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, is the backbone of healthcare data protection in the U.S. It establishes nationwide standards for handling health information and is non-negotiable for AI therapy providers.

Under HIPAA, the Privacy Rule protects identifiable health data and grants individuals access to their health records. Meanwhile, the Security Rule focuses on safeguarding electronic health information created, received, or transmitted by covered entities, such as clinicians, health plans, and clearinghouses. These entities, along with Business Associates handling Protected Health Information (PHI), must have Business Associate Agreements (BAAs) in place to ensure compliance [2].

For patients in substance use disorder treatment programs, 42 CFR Part 2 provides an added layer of privacy. Unlike HIPAA - which allows data sharing for treatment, payment, or healthcare operations without explicit consent - 42 CFR Part 2 mandates either patient consent or a recognized exception for such disclosures [2].

State laws are also stepping in to address AI-specific concerns. For instance, California's AB 3030, effective January 1, 2025, will require healthcare facilities using generative AI to inform patients that the communication was AI-generated and provide them with a way to reach a human provider [4]. Similarly, Utah's Artificial Intelligence Policy Act, slated for May 2025, will demand clear disclosures about AI use in healthcare communications [4].

Consent and Data Privacy Requirements

In AI therapy, consent forms must outline exactly how PHI will be used. These documents should specify the type of data being used, who is authorized to use it, the purpose, the receiving party, and an expiration date [2].

PHI covers a wide range of information, including an individual’s past, present, or future health conditions, the care they receive, and payments for those services [2].

Data security is a top priority. As Raz Karmi, CISO at Eleos Health, emphasizes:

"We need [AI] to be HIPAA-compliant. That's something that we can't compromise on." – Raz Karmi, CISO at Eleos Health [6]

Karmi also warns about the stakes for organizations:

"The smallest breach could kill a business today." – Raz Karmi, CISO at Eleos Health [6]

Key security practices include encrypting data during transmission and storage, minimizing the data collected, and enforcing strict access controls. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services provides specific guidelines for HIPAA-compliant data storage, which apply to covered entities and their Business Associates [2].

Even organizations not bound by HIPAA are encouraged to follow its guidelines to protect patient privacy and maintain trust.

Changing Legal Guidelines

As AI regulations evolve, so do consent protocols and compliance requirements. States are taking varied approaches to address AI in healthcare. Massachusetts, for example, has proposed bill H1974, which would require licensed mental health professionals to gain approval from their licensing boards before incorporating AI into clinical practice. If passed, this would also mandate informed consent and the option for patients to choose human treatment [5].

In Georgia, HB887 seeks to ensure that insurance coverage and healthcare decisions cannot rely solely on AI or automated tools. It would require a meaningful review by an authorized individual who can override AI decisions [5].

Federal discussions are also underway, with some considering a temporary pause on states’ abilities to regulate AI. This could complicate efforts to enforce AI-related laws across multiple jurisdictions [3].

Rony Gadiwalla, CIO at GRAND Mental Health, highlights the importance of addressing these challenges:

"You want that comfort level. You want that transparency." – Rony Gadiwalla, CIO at GRAND Mental Health [6]

To manage these complexities, organizations should form cross-functional AI committees that include clinicians, compliance officers, and IT experts. Thorough vetting of vendors - especially regarding encryption, access controls, and data retention - is also critical [6].

The rise of mobile health applications adds another layer of difficulty. Since 2022, 63% of U.S. adults have used mobile health apps. Many of these apps collect additional data, such as tracking information (88%), cookies or identifiers (around two-thirds), and email addresses (about one-third) [8].

To stay ahead, healthcare providers must create clear internal AI policies that define privacy standards, security protocols, and vendor requirements. As regulations shift, maintaining transparency will remain key to earning and keeping patient trust.

Core Principles of Informed Consent for AI Therapy

Therapists must adhere to key principles to ensure AI therapy remains ethical, transparent, and centered on the needs of the patient. These principles are not just about meeting legal requirements - they create a foundation of trust and accountability in the therapeutic process.

Transparency in AI Use

Transparency is the cornerstone of ethical AI therapy. Therapists must openly explain how AI systems function, addressing aspects like algorithmic processes, interactions, and broader implications. Tools such as Explainable AI (XAI), which provide clear explanations for AI decisions, play a crucial role here. Transparency involves:

• Algorithmic transparency: Clearly outlining the logic, processes, and algorithms behind the AI system.
• Interaction transparency: Informing clients when AI is part of the therapeutic process and how it contributes.
• Social transparency: Discussing the ethical and societal impacts of using AI in therapy.

As noted in the Zendesk CX Trends Report 2024:

"Being transparent about the data that drives AI models and their decisions will be a defining element in building and maintaining trust with customers" [9].

Such openness ensures clients feel informed and empowered, which is essential for voluntary participation in AI-assisted therapy.

Voluntary Participation and Opt-Out Options

Respecting patient autonomy is non-negotiable. For informed consent to be meaningful, clients must have the freedom to choose whether or not to engage with AI tools. Therapists should make it clear that declining AI involvement will not affect the quality of care or the therapeutic relationship. Alternative options should always be available.

For example, if using AI for note-taking, a therapist might ask: "I use an AI tool for note-taking during sessions. Would you prefer I take notes manually instead?" [11].

Documenting patient preferences and ensuring they can question or reject AI outputs at any time is critical. This approach ensures clients retain control over their therapeutic experience [11][12].

Data Privacy and Security

Protecting patient data is paramount, especially in mental health care where the information is deeply personal. AI applications in therapy require stricter safeguards than those used in general consumer contexts. Unlike systems processing social media or e-commerce data, AI in mental health handles highly sensitive information [7].

The risks are real. A 2022 study in JAMA Network Open revealed that 29 of 36 mental health apps shared user data with third parties, often without proper consent. Furthermore, 79% of Americans express concern about how companies handle their health data [14]. The 2020 Vastaamo data breach in Finland, which exposed over 25,000 therapy records, underscores the devastating consequences of inadequate protections [14].

To address these challenges, therapists and organizations should:

• Collect only the data necessary for therapeutic purposes.
• Encrypt all data during transmission and storage.
• Implement strict access controls and conduct regular security audits.
• Establish Business Associate Agreements (BAAs) with AI technology vendors to ensure compliance with privacy standards [13][14].

Platforms like Gaslighting Check demonstrate how privacy can be prioritized. This tool analyzes conversations to detect emotional manipulation while safeguarding user data through encryption and automatic deletion policies. It proves that AI can enhance mental health support without compromising confidentiality.

Ultimately, AI should act as a tool to complement a therapist’s expertise, improving efficiency without replacing human judgment. When privacy and security are managed effectively, AI can enhance therapy while preserving the trust that is vital to the patient-therapist relationship.

Ethical Challenges and Risk Mitigation

Expanding on the importance of legal and ethical consent, this section delves into the risks and strategies crucial for managing AI in therapy. With mental health conditions affecting 970 million people worldwide and costing the global economy about $2.5 trillion in 2010 - a figure expected to soar to $6 trillion by 2030 [1] - addressing these challenges is critical. Safeguarding patients and preserving trust in therapeutic relationships must remain top priorities.

Bias and Discrimination in AI Algorithms

AI algorithms, while powerful, can unintentionally perpetuate biases, leading to unequal diagnosis and treatment for underrepresented groups [16]. Since these systems learn from historical data, they may adopt and reinforce existing prejudices unless the data used is diverse and inclusive [10]. Additionally, culturally specific expressions of mental distress - especially those outside Western diagnostic norms - can be overlooked or misinterpreted, further marginalizing certain populations [17].

To address these issues, organizations should:

• Use diverse and representative datasets.
• Conduct regular fairness assessments of algorithms.
• Continuously update and refine systems to reflect inclusivity [15].

As Rony Gadiwalla, CIO of GRAND Mental Health, aptly puts it:

"It's important to recognize that AI is not going to work unattended. It seems like regulations change on a daily basis. You really have to be proactive" [19].

Regular Review of Consent Processes

Consent in AI therapy isn’t static - it’s a dynamic and ongoing process. As AI technology evolves, so do its risks and capabilities, making it essential to revisit and update consent protocols regularly. Vivian Chung Easton, LMFT, CHC, Clinical Product Lead at Blueprint, emphasizes this point:

"Remember, informed consent is an ongoing process, not a one-time event. As AI capabilities change, so should your consent discussions. Make it a habit to regularly check in with clients about their comfort level with AI and address any new developments or concerns that arise" [11].

Organizations should ensure that consent processes include periodic check-ins with clients, thorough documentation of technology use, and alignment with current ethical and legal standards. With 45 states introducing AI-related bills and 31 adopting new regulations in 2024 alone [19], staying compliant requires constant vigilance. Monitoring client outcomes and swiftly addressing any adverse effects are also key to maintaining ethical practices.

Best Practices for Ethical AI Use

Strong data governance lies at the heart of ethical AI implementation. To protect sensitive information, organizations should adopt measures such as:

• Role-based access controls.
• Encryption protocols.
• Regular risk assessments to meet regulations like HIPAA, HITECH, and GDPR [18].

Given that the average healthcare data breach in 2023 cost nearly $11 million - and over half of these breaches stemmed from internal sources - robust security measures are non-negotiable [18]. Privacy-by-design principles, such as collecting only essential data and de-identifying patient information, add another layer of protection [18].

Equally important are transparency and explainability. Mental health professionals must clearly articulate how AI systems process data and make decisions [7][17]. Shared accountability between organizations and AI vendors, ongoing monitoring, and open knowledge-sharing are critical to maintaining ethical standards.

Tools like Gaslighting Check illustrate how these principles can be applied effectively. By analyzing conversations for emotional manipulation while adhering to strict privacy safeguards, such tools enhance mental health support without compromising ethical values.

Together, these practices help build trust and ensure that AI-assisted therapy operates with integrity and respect for patients.

How to Implement Informed Consent for AI Therapy

For AI-assisted therapy to succeed, therapists and organizations need to implement informed consent processes that build trust. With 79% of Americans concerned about how companies handle their personal health data [14], transparency is not just a best practice - it's essential. Below, we'll explore how to create clear consent documentation, train staff effectively, and establish strong privacy protections to ensure informed consent is meaningful and actionable.

Creating Clear Consent Documentation

Consent forms should be straightforward, well-organized, and focused on their purpose. Start with a title that clearly states the document pertains to AI-assisted therapy. The introduction should briefly explain the form's purpose and outline how AI will be used in the therapeutic process [20].

The main body of the document must address key points. Be upfront about the AI system's role, including how long it will be used, what it requires, and how it processes data. Clearly explain both the benefits and risks so clients can make informed decisions [20]. Include details on how data will be collected, stored, and protected, ensuring clients understand how their personal information will be handled.

A statement of informed consent should follow, along with spaces for signatures and dates. Use plain, everyday language - steer clear of technical terms or jargon - and format the document in a way that's easy to read. Fonts should be legible, and the layout should guide the reader naturally through the content.

When it comes to AI-specific disclosures, transparency is critical. Clients need to know the system's capabilities, limitations, and potential uncertainties. As Blueprint.ai puts it:

"Patients need to know when and how AI is used in their care... Be clear about AI's capabilities and limitations, and disclose any potential risks or uncertainties."

• Blueprint.ai [11]

This means explaining what data the AI will analyze, how it processes information, and its decision-making limitations [21]. Allow room for patient questions and concerns, and provide detailed information about how the AI fits into the broader therapeutic process.

To maintain accuracy and accountability, assign version numbers or dates to the consent forms and have them reviewed by supervisors, ethics committees, or legal advisors. Ensure they comply with regulations like HIPAA and any state-specific laws. Always provide clients with a copy for their records.

Once the documentation is in place, the next step is ensuring staff are trained to communicate these details effectively.

Training and Communication Strategies

Healthcare professionals need thorough training to confidently explain AI systems and address patient concerns during consent discussions [22]. Training programs should cover both the technical aspects of AI - such as how it processes data and its limitations - and how it integrates with traditional therapy methods.

Effective communication is equally important. Tailor your approach to each patient’s needs. Use plain language, visual aids, or interactive tools to break down complex AI concepts [22]. Some clients may want detailed technical explanations, while others might prefer simpler, more practical descriptions.

Informed consent is not a one-time event - it’s an ongoing process. Regularly check in with clients about their comfort levels and address any new concerns or developments. Document these conversations in clinical notes for transparency and accountability.

Prepare staff for common questions about data privacy, AI accuracy, and human oversight. Develop standard but honest responses that address uncertainties without overpromising.

Building Trust Through Privacy Protections

Strong privacy measures are key to building trust. Use robust encryption and strict access controls to safeguard sensitive data. Collect only the information you need - this practice, known as data minimization, reduces risks [14]. Clearly define data retention policies and securely delete or anonymize data once it’s no longer needed [23].

Transparency about how data will be used is critical. A 2022 study revealed that 29 out of 36 mental health apps shared user data with third parties, often without proper consent [14]. To avoid such pitfalls, ensure clients understand exactly how their information will be handled before it’s used [23].

Tools like Gaslighting Check are good examples of privacy-conscious implementation. They analyze conversations for emotional manipulation while using encrypted data and automatic deletion policies to protect user information.

Compliance with regulations like HIPAA, GDPR, and CCPA must be an ongoing effort. Regular audits and privacy-by-design principles - where data protection is built into every layer of the AI system - help ensure compliance [14].

Empower clients by giving them control over their data. Offer options for data export and deletion, and respect their decisions about AI involvement without penalizing them or reducing the quality of care.

Finally, regularly monitor and evaluate AI systems to maintain their reliability and effectiveness. By committing to privacy and transparency, therapists and organizations can build lasting trust, making informed consent a tool that truly empowers clients.

Conclusion

Informed consent in AI therapy is a cornerstone of ethical practice and client protection. Building on the principles and legal guidelines discussed earlier, it's clear that implementing informed consent requires more than just a one-time acknowledgment - it's an ongoing process.

Therapists need a solid grasp of AI's capabilities, limitations, and data practices. As Jeffrey Parsons, PhD, NCC, LPCC-S, Counselor Educator, points out:

"The first thing is just keeping to the basics of ethical practice. If you look at the ACA Code of Ethics, the NBCC Code of Ethics, some of those underlying principles always apply. We already know client welfare has to be the priority. That hasn't changed with AI." [24]

Clear and upfront communication is essential. Clients should fully understand how AI will be integrated into their care, how their data will be handled, and that they can opt out of AI involvement without any impact on the quality of their treatment. Regular updates and open conversations are key to maintaining trust throughout the therapeutic process.

Privacy and security are non-negotiable. Therapists must use tools that comply with HIPAA standards to protect client data. Parsons underscores this point:

"Most of the platforms out there are not meant for health care practice; they aren't HIPAA compliant. You can't just plug client information into ChatGPT, because you're essentially feeding client data into the public domain." [24]

Ethical practice also means preserving the human connection in therapy. AI should support - not replace - clinical judgment and the therapeutic bond. Experts stress the importance of balancing technological advancements with the foundational priority of client welfare, ensuring AI is implemented responsibly and with proper oversight.

For therapists and organizations, this means committing to continuous improvement. Staff training, updated consent forms that reflect evolving technologies, and open discussions with clients about their concerns and comfort levels all play a role in refining the consent process.

FAQs

::: faq

How do HIPAA and 42 CFR Part 2 differ in AI therapy, and what do these differences mean for patient consent?

HIPAA and 42 CFR Part 2: Understanding Privacy Standards

The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) sets the groundwork for protecting health information across the U.S. It allows disclosures of health data for purposes like treatment, payment, and healthcare operations, provided the patient gives consent. HIPAA also permits re-disclosure, as long as it complies with its regulations.

On the other hand, 42 CFR Part 2 zeroes in on the confidentiality of records related to substance use disorder treatment. This regulation is much stricter, requiring explicit, written consent from patients before any disclosures can be made. A recent change has made the process slightly more flexible, allowing patients to give a single, broad consent for future disclosures.

When it comes to AI therapy, these regulations play a crucial role in shaping how patient consent is handled. HIPAA offers more leeway for general health information, whereas 42 CFR Part 2 enforces tighter controls, especially for substance use records, ensuring a higher level of privacy. :::

::: faq

How can therapists maintain informed consent when using AI tools in therapy, given the fast-changing nature of AI technology and regulations?

Therapists can ensure informed consent by crafting clear, detailed consent forms that outline how AI is integrated into therapy. These forms should explain what AI tools can and cannot do, along with how client data is handled. Regular updates to these forms are crucial as AI technology and regulations evolve.

Equally important is open communication. Therapists should talk openly with clients about the use of AI, addressing any questions or concerns. Clients should also have the option to decline the use of AI-based tools if they prefer. Keeping thorough records of consent updates and notifying clients about significant changes helps therapists stay aligned with ethical and legal requirements in the U.S. :::

::: faq

How can organizations reduce biases in AI therapy tools, and why is this important for patient outcomes?

To make AI therapy tools fairer, organizations should focus on a few key strategies: frequent algorithm audits, using diverse and inclusive training datasets, and maintaining human oversight in decision-making. These practices help spot and reduce biases that might otherwise slip through unnoticed.

Why does this matter? Biases in AI can lead to misdiagnoses, ineffective treatment plans, and even greater health disparities, especially for marginalized groups. Tackling these challenges head-on not only improves patient care but also helps create a mental health system that's fairer and more effective for everyone. :::